Seafood Dilemma

January 26, 2010
by zahirah

Thanks to Laura for sharing this list of seafood recommendations under the Seafood Watch section of the California Monterey Bay Aquarium website.

With all I’ve been reading about the food industry lately, I decided to check out the links to the most popular fish we have down here and see how our fish options stand:

Hake
This might be a good option, depending on what kind of hake it is. Signs at the grocery store or fish markets just say “merluza,” so there’s no saying there. Some hake is a good alternative, and other (white) hake should be avoided.  It’s all from the Atlantic, so who knows.

Salmon
I’d assume we’re getting farmed salmon down here, so that’s a terrible option. There are several huge fish farms in Chile, and I think they mainly produce salmon. So that’s clearly not a sustainable choice.

Sole
Since we’ve got an Atlantic coast, I’d assume we’re getting Atlantic and not Pacific sole, which apparently is being overfished, unlike its Pacific counterpart. Atlantic sole is marked as “avoid.”

Rainbow Trout
From the options on the list, which are all US trout, it’s hard to tell whether our trout down here is a good or bad choice. I know they can be found “naturally” in rivers and lakes in the Patagonia (they’re not native but were introduced years ago), but where is the stuff we buy in the grocery store coming from? My first guess would be farms, which is not good.

So, from the looks of it, fish is a terrible choice for sustainable eating in Argentina, which leads me to re-think our diet.

I think I’ll go pick up some tofu tomorrow after the gym. It’s been a while since I made that for a meal. Though, I can probably guarantee you it’s made with GMO soy. Eating is so frustrating these days, if I actually stop and take the time to think about where my meal is coming from.

2 Responses leave one →
  1. January 26, 2010

    Hey Holly,

    Your best choice is to eat at the places you know there’s fishing activity involved. For an example, say Mar del Plata (although it’s commercial fishing). But if you ever go north (from Zarate up to Corrientes or Misiones) you’ll see along the way a lot of people selling fishes like Surubi or Dorado (salt water fish) that are delicious to be grilled cooked or fried (particularly the surubi). These are fished by hand (or say, pole) from the river and are usually sold either as food, or as a consolation for those who actually went fishing and came back bare handed. These would actually count as free range fish (surubies for an example, are never “farmed”) though they may be a bit less delicious than lox :D

  2. January 29, 2010

    Thanks!! Good suggestions…but what to do in Buenos Aires? Plus, I just read all about mercury poisoning from fish, and now THAT freaks me out. Eating fish sounds like a lose-lose situation, unless we raise our own…which is clearly not an option!!

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS